18 Comments
User's avatar
Optional's avatar

George Floyd very clearly self-overdosed. He wasn't murdered by a policeman.

Don't repeat leftist tropes if you are unhappy about all the damage they do.

George Avery's avatar

True - and the methamphetamine in the counterfeit Percocet he was given by a friend masked many of the usual signs of opiate overdose, so you honestly cannot even blame the officers for failing to recognize the problem and administer Narcan.

I don't blame Floyd for his death, either. He had been legitimately prescribed Percocet and obtained a tablet (that happened to be counterfeit) from a friend - technically illegal but not an uncommon practice. Such tablets managed to get into the supply chain in the Twin Cities - Prince Rogers Nelson died of the same type of overdose from a tablet dispended with a prescription from a local pharmacy in the Twin Cities area. The murderer was the creator and distributor of the counterfeits.

Floyd's underlying conditions likely made even a Narcan recovery problematic. The autopsy showed he had several coronary arteries already blocked to a point seen in many individuals undergoing an active AMI. If you add on the potential impact of the methamphetamine on cardiac rhythms and the impact of reduced blood oxygen levels due to the opiate-induced respiratory depression, lethal cardiac arrest was almost inevitable had he been sitting at home peacefully watching TV.

The claims that pressure on his neck killed him were clear and blatant misrepresentations intended to placate the Leftist mob, and what happened to those officers in the courtroom amounted to a legally sanctioned lynching.

I'm not a great fan of the MPD - the one interaction I had with them as a grad student at the UM in the early 2000s was with a very arrogant officer who obviously felt his badge meant his fecal byproducts smelled like roses while he wrote a ticket for a burned out taillight on my Jeep (as opposed to the more common law enforcement practice of issuing a warning as a notification of the problem). That doesn't mean that their officers are murderers for subduing a delusional criminal and having him die on them from the counterfeit medication he took thinking it was the drug he had been prescribed for his back pain issues.

George Avery's avatar

Practical research is less cited because papers building on it tend to violate the narratives and thus not get accepted.

My own experience is with a paper I wrote looking at intergovernmental funding to local health departments through the federal bioterrorism preparedness program, using data from over 1700 local departments. I found that the federal funds had NO impact on local preparedness planning activities - but having dedicated local leadership DID result in such activity. In short, local leadership, not funding, determines what gets done. The top public health journals - edited by individuals who had been vocal that the problems with the public health system are the result of resource shortages - returned the paper without sending it for review. I sent it to a very respectable general health policy journal and saw it reviewed, accepted, and in print within six weeks.

Things are worse than Kuhn described. Now, you not only have to fit within the scientific paradigm to be published, but within the prevailing political narrative.

Robert Anthony Maranto's avatar

This is a really interesting comment. Can you e-mail me the citation to the paper. (Robert Maranto at the U of Arkansas).

George Avery's avatar

Robert - no problem. By the way, I received my MPA from UALR while working for the state health department in the 1990s.

The paper I mentioned is:

Avery GH and Zabriskie J. (2009) The Impact of Federal Bioterrorism Funding Programs on Local Health Department Preparedness Activities. Evaluation and the Health Professions 32(2): 95-127.

A complementary one is:

Avery GH, Wright TJ. (2010) Does Federal Assistance to Health Departments for Bioterrorism Preparedness Improve Local Public Health Activity? An Empirical Evaluation Using the 2005 NACCHO Profile of Local Health Departments. Journal of Homeland Security and Emergency Management 7(1): Article 11.

It uses the same data set and examines the question of whether the funding led to changes in OTHER public health programs. Answer: No.

Pawlus's avatar

The authors' search criteria strike me as dubious. Zimring's book has already been cited by dozens of journal articles as can easily be seen by going to Google scholar, so it seems pretty careless or disingenuous to act as though this book isn't getting any serious attention. BLM is a social movement so it shouldn't be surprising that articles using that phrase would tend to focus on that aspect of it.

Armst's avatar

In other words, academia and science are crap and worthless and should be shunned. Got it.

George Avery's avatar

There is good work that sneaks through, but serious reforms are needed in the funding and dissemination processes - not to mention in tenure decisions, which have been used to eliminate those who do not fit a prevailing narrative. Trustees at universities need to review not only the P&T files of those faculty committees decide to award tenure to, but also those that they recommend denying tenure to - and review them critically, with the faculty decisions being viewed as only advisory and the trustee reviewers accepting that the responsibility for decisions resides in them.

Optional's avatar

The trustees haven't got a clue who is qualified.

And even if they were - they are more politically compromised and controlled than even the faculty. The problem with academia is coming from the top down.

George Avery's avatar

The tenure problem is bottom up.

Optional's avatar

I have no idea what your comment means.

The tenure problem is that tenure exists at all. And I an say that as tenured full professor.

Academia is intellectually stunted and ideologically monolithic because of tenure.

Tenure makes the incentives to conform (or be quiet) during pre-tenure extremely high.

And nobody changes after tenure. The invested effort by that point is far too high to risk opprobrium by speaking up against the (now leftist) orthodoxies.

Opinions that leftists dislike are fully socially and professionally punished anyway and the existence of tenure doesn't stop the leftist cult from doing it.

TGGP's avatar

A paper on "public health" as well as on "differential mortality" could be relevant to saving "black lives", even if BLM kicked off in reaction to (small as a share of total deaths) shootings by police. I haven't actually read these papers though, so can't say how plausible it is that they could save lives.

George Avery's avatar

The Left basically opposes any work on the topic that controls for things like local crime rates, crime rates by victim race, race of the officer, conjunction between officer race and victim race, victim criminal record, rates of violent crime by race, etc. that would potentially undercut the narrative that all police shootings are the result of white racism.

TGGP's avatar

Perhaps, but not especially relevant to the topic of a paper on "public health".

George Avery's avatar

However, the academic public health community is currently invested in the idea of "equity" and "antiracism," which largely precludes getting such work funded or published in public health journals.

One only has to look at CDC's opposition to John Lott's research

George Avery's avatar

Or Harvard's reaction to Ronald Fryer's work on racial disparities in police shootings. Fryer, a black economics professor, found greater use of force against black suspects at lower levels of force, which declined as force escalated with no differences in shootings associated with race. Harvard faculty immediately began attacking him over his findings, He was then subject to 38 complaints of sexually harassing graduate students. Thirty-two were dismissed after investigation as fabrications, while the remaining six were ruled uncertain based on lack of clear evidence one way or another. Nevertheless, he was suspended without pay by the faculty for two years, barred from supervising graduate students, and had his research lab shut down.

Fryer was not a fly-by-night researcher. He won the 2015 Clark Medal as the top economist under the age of 40 and was considered a potential future Nobel Laureate.